Edtech

Teachers Want Better Materials and Better Tools. Let’s Give Them Both.

4 Min Read
Illustration of educator using edtech tools

Summary

Teachers benefit from AI tools and instructional materials that work with high-quality curriculum to preserve instructional coherence while providing greater flexibility.

The latest survey from Educators for Excellence shows that teachers almost universally support high-quality curriculum. We’ve spent decades as a field working to get stronger, more coherent materials into classrooms. Seeing this kind of teacher support for high-quality instruction is a powerful sign of how far that work has come.

At the same time, teachers are telling us where they still need more support—and increasingly, they’re turning to AI to fill those gaps.

Most teachers report having the flexibility to adapt their curriculum, yet only about half feel they have adequate supplemental materials for students who need additional support. Teachers are finding other ways to get what they need: two-thirds now report using AI to differentiate lessons for different learners, generate quizzes, and adapt instructional materials.

This trend risks recreating the very problem the high-quality instructional materials movement set out to fix. It wasn’t long ago that teachers were routinely writing their own lessons or pulling materials from third-party websites, with no guarantee that those resources were consistent or connected to what students learned before and after. High-quality curriculum was meant to change that. But if teachers now turn to a disconnected AI chatbot for their supplemental materials, we risk undoing much of that progress.

High-quality programs follow a careful design, from specific content to the order in which skills are taught. When a standalone chatbot generates a lesson or quiz, that connection can get lost.

For example, if you were to go to your chatbot of choice right now and ask it to draft a first-grade reading lesson, it would generate one. But does it reinforce the skills students are learning in their core curriculum? Is it appropriate for where they are in the sequence? And does it meet the same bar for quality? Checking every AI-generated lesson against the curriculum is one more task on an already full plate.

Teachers are worried about this too. In fact, their top concern about AI tools is the inconsistent quality of the content it produces.

If teachers are going to use AI to adapt and supplement their curriculum, those tools should reinforce the sequence and content students are already learning, not introduce disconnected material alongside it.

Better tools that work with the curriculum, not around it

We have an opportunity here to give teachers the flexibility and support AI offers without losing the coherence that makes high-quality curriculum effective in the first place.

An integrated AI tool that reinforces core curriculum could draw from a vetted bank of questions tied directly to the skills students are already working on. This would provide teachers with the on-demand adaptability to respond to what their students need, while the supplemental material builds on what came before and supports what comes next.

We have an opportunity here to give teachers the flexibility and support AI offers without losing the coherence that makes high-quality curriculum effective in the first place.

Lindsay Dworkin

Senior Vice President, Policy & Government Affairs at HMH

 

Better materials mean fewer gaps to fill

The other half of the solution is reducing how often teachers have to improvise in the first place. It’s clear from the survey that core programs need stronger intervention and differentiation supports that are built-in. Every disconnected resource is one more thing a teacher has to vet, adapt, and squeeze into their already packed day. Better materials give teachers that time back, and give students extra support that’s held to the same standard as their core instruction.

The role district and state leaders can play

Leaders hold significant leverage here. It starts with what they choose to buy.

When evaluating AI tools, district leaders should ask: Does this tool protect the integrity of our instructional materials, or does it work around them? Evaluation and purchasing criteria can make that question explicit.

Teachers should also have a voice in those decisions. We’ve seen the value of involving educators in curriculum adoption, and the same should be true for AI integration. No one is better positioned to decide whether a tool strengthens their lessons or simply gives them one more thing to manage.

Policies should also distinguish between educator-facing and student-facing AI. A tool that helps a teacher plan a lesson, differentiate instruction, or create an assessment raises different questions than a tool students use directly. Guidance should reflect those differences, giving teachers room to benefit from AI while being more thoughtful about when and how students use it.

Finally, leaders can help make strong, coherent support the default rather than the exception. States should consider whether curriculum reviews assess the quality of built-in intervention and differentiation supports, while districts should prioritize supplemental materials that align with their core curriculum. Districts can also set aside dedicated professional learning time so teachers can feel confident putting those supports to work—because even the best resources only help if teachers know how to use them.

Key takeaways

  • High-quality curriculum should include stronger intervention and differentiation supports, reducing the need for teachers to find or create supplemental resources.
  • Curriculum-connected AI that reinforce the sequence, content, and quality of instruction can give teachers greater flexibility while maintaining the instructional coherence students need across lessons and skills.
  • Teachers should have a voice in AI purchasing decisions because they are best positioned to evaluate whether tools strengthen instruction or add complexity.

 

***

For more articles on trends in education from experts, subscribe to HMH's LinkedIn newsletter, Policy in Motion.

We want to hear from you! For questions, comments, or feedback, please contact us at shaped@hmhco.com or follow us on Instagram, LinkedIn, and YouTube.

Protect student data with help from our AI privacy guide.