We know it’s important to encourage our students to adopt a growth mindset towards their mathematical abilities. But when we draw a smiley face on a student’s paper or say “good job,” are we building a growth or a fixed mindset? These types of math feedback are meant to encourage but they fail to give students specific information about what they did well or their next steps in learning. This nonspecific praise can cause students to attribute success to ability rather than effort.
Actionable Math Feedback Examples
Actionable or descriptive feedback in math supports student learning. It also helps students to take ownership for their learning and see how to focus their learning efforts. In their book INFORMative Assessment, published by Heinemann, authors Jeane Joyner and Mari Muri define actionable feedback as:
“…information that is descriptive, telling students what is correct or incorrect and suggesting where students might go next. It gives students enough information so that they have an idea of what they need to rethink or how to improve, but not so much direction that the thinking is done for them.” (2011, p. 254)
Actionable feedback in the math classroom demonstrates the teacher’s belief in student potential which contributes to a growth mindset.
Examples of actionable feedback:
- “Your answer is correct but your explanation isn’t clear. How can you communicate your process for solving this problem so that others can see your thinking?”
- “You’ve found two solutions for this task. Do you think there are others? How might you find out?”
- “Your procedure makes sense but there are some computational errors. What are some ways you can check your work for accuracy?”
Questions for Teacher Reflection
- How might you examine the types of feedback you currently provide for your students?
- What are some ways you could refine your skills in crafting and offering actionable math feedback for students?
- How might you monitor the impact of your feedback on student learning, and on your students’ attitudes towards mathematics and themselves as math learners?
Partner with HMH for coaching, courses, and professional development that supports you every step of the way.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of HMH.
Dr. Linda Lucey
Associate Partner, ICLE
Lead Instructional Designer, ICLE
Zoe Del Mar